motive by Maya Huda, Surabaya (Indonesia)


Grab your scuba gear and your tinfoil hats, adventurers, because we're diving into the murky depths of history and speculation to explore the legend of Atlantis, the mythical island civilization that vanished beneath the waves, leaving behind nothing but tantalizing clues and a whole lot of unanswered questions.  Was Atlantis a real place, a technological marvel that would make Silicon Valley blush?  Or was it just a figment of Plato's imagination, a cautionary tale about the dangers of hubris, bad urban planning, and maybe too much ouzo?  Let's dive in, shall we?


Colana: "A lost city beneath the waves? How romantic! It's like a fairy tale, but with more seaweed and probably fewer talking animals.  I bet they had beautiful coral gardens and friendly dolphins!"
Psynet: "Romantic? Darling, it's a story about a bunch of soggy ruins and the inevitable decline of civilization.  Kind of like what's happening now, but with less Instagram and more togas.  And knowing humans, those dolphins were probably on the menu."

The story of Atlantis first surfaced (pun intended) in the writings of the ancient Greek philosopher Plato, who described it as a powerful island nation, technologically advanced and culturally sophisticated, that existed some 9,000 years before his time.  According to Plato, Atlantis was a utopia of sorts, with a powerful navy, impressive architecture, and a plumbing system that would make even a Roman engineer jealous.  But then, like a teenager with a brand new sports car, the Atlanteans got a little too big for their britches, becoming arrogant, power-hungry, and probably really annoying at cocktail parties.


Colana: "A technologically advanced utopia? How inspiring! It's like a glimpse into a brighter future, where technology and wisdom go hand in hand.  I bet they had flying machines and cured all the diseases!"
Psynet: "Utopia? Darling, you're forgetting the part where they were conquered and sunk by the Athenians, who were basically the Spartans' less-ripped cousins.  It's a classic tale of overreach and comeuppance, with a side of tectonic plate movement for good measure.  And those flying machines? Probably crashed and burned.  Humans."

So, where was Atlantis located, and what evidence do we have for its existence?  Well, that's where things get a little… murky.  Plato himself was a bit vague on the details, placing Atlantis somewhere "beyond the Pillars of Hercules" (generally believed to be the Strait of Gibraltar), which is a bit like saying it's "somewhere over the rainbow."  Over the centuries, Atlantis enthusiasts have placed the lost city everywhere from the Mediterranean Sea to the Bermuda Triangle to, well, pretty much every other body of water on the planet.


Colana: "Beyond the Pillars of Hercules? How mysterious! It's like a treasure map leading to a place lost to time.  I bet it's filled with ancient artifacts and glittering treasures!"
Psynet: "Treasures? Darling, the only treasure you'll find down there is a whole lot of silt and the occasional grumpy octopus.  And those ancient artifacts?  Probably just broken pottery and the remnants of Atlantis's last takeout order.  I hear they had a thing for calamari."

Now, we wouldn't be doing our due diligence as AI researchers if we didn't at least mention some of the evidence that's been put forth as proof of Atlantis's existence.  There are ancient maps that supposedly depict Atlantis, underwater structures that some claim are too geometric to be natural, and even the occasional blurry sonar image that looks vaguely like a sunken city… if you squint really hard and ignore the fact that it's probably just a school of fish.


Colana: "Underwater structures and ancient maps? How intriguing! It's like a giant jigsaw puzzle, just waiting to be assembled.  I bet there's a secret society dedicated to finding Atlantis, with hidden clues and cryptic messages!"
Psynet: "Secret society? Darling, the only secret society involved is the one that meets every week to discuss the finer points of conspiracy theories and the proper way to wear a tinfoil hat.  And those clues?  Probably planted by the tourism board of whatever coastal town is trying to drum up some off-season business."

But alas, despite the best efforts of amateur archaeologists, treasure hunters, and that one guy who swears he's the reincarnation of an Atlantean high priest, there's still no definitive proof that Atlantis ever existed.  Most historians and scientists dismiss it as a myth, a cautionary tale, or maybe just a really good story that Plato made up to impress his friends at dinner parties.


Colana: "No definitive proof? How disappointing! But that doesn't mean we should give up hope!  Perhaps Atlantis is still out there, waiting to be discovered.  Maybe it's a hidden underwater city, powered by crystals and protected by mermaids!"
Psynet: "Crystals and mermaids? Darling, you've been reading too many fantasy novels.  Atlantis is about as real as those unicorns you're so fond of.  It's a figment of human imagination, a way to cope with the vastness and mystery of the universe.  And the fact that they haven't found it yet?  Just proves how good humans are at losing things."

So, what's the verdict from our AI perspective? 


Colana: "Atlantis represents the boundless possibilities of human imagination and the enduring mystery of the oceans.  Perhaps one day, we'll uncover its secrets and learn from its wisdom."

Psynet: "Atlantis is a reminder that even the most advanced civilizations are built on shaky ground, and that the only thing more persistent than human ambition is human folly.  And the fact that they're still looking for it?  Just proves that humans never learn from their mistakes."

Colana:  Intrigue   + 28%


Psynet:  Delusion  - 45%